Eoin_C wrote:
If it insists on pre-selecting the first user to log in, I want it to be the one I actually use, not one I created just for testing purposes.
Suppose you have two user accounts on your machine: Joe and Bill. You're Joe. You don't want Bill's login screen automatically presented every time you boot your machine, you want your own.
If it didn't pre-select any user by default, that would be one thing. But consistently pre-selecting the wrong user every time is getting really annoying.
Did you try pressing Option + Enter on the login screen to see if it would revert the login screen to the old style where no user was the default? This would give you what you want....the old style of logging in. Or try @John Galt's suggestion of hiding the user accounts although I do urge caution since I have seen some macOS bugs/issues with hiding user accounts.
I had seen this suggested by someone on this forum & I only tried it on one laptop, but it appeared to work (it wasn't my laptop or one I use all the time which is why I tried it so I cannot say for sure it lasts although it survived multiple reboots).
Another option is to forego showing macOS user accounts at all and go with manually entering the username along with the password.
Here are several forum posts from as far back as 2015 with the same question.....guess what, there are no solutions to selecting a default user account for the login screen. If anyone does know, they haven't shared it with anyone and it would not involve the GUI interface.
https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/480465/specify-default-user-for-macos-sequoia-login-screen
How to set default user at login screen? … - Apple Community
https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/291492/how-to-set-a-default-user-on-the-login-screen-without-automatically-logging-in