Yeti mic stopped working during phone calls

I've been using my Yeti microphone for years to talk on the phone when answering from my mac, but it suddenly stopped working last week. It works for every other application and when I go to sound settings, I can see the input sensor moving when I talk on it. The only time it doesn't work is during a phone call.

It is definitely selected as the input mic under sound settings!

And yes, I tried to check the security settings under "Microphone" and there's no phone/facetime app for me to select/deselect. I've also tried rebooting and plugging/unplugging my mic and still nothing.