My proxy import has no audio after choosing "remove silent channels'.

I have a 90 minute live video that was shot on 3 good SONY cameras.

Some are contiguous and some are broken up into non-contiguous clips. I am trying to make a video via a multi clip where everything is synched via audio from each clip. Then I will, after having them all in synch, add an edited audio track from my audio DAW to replace all the audio for the final edit.


the three camera file types are:

MP4: 3840 × 2160. Linear PCM, HEVC

MXF files

MP4: 3840 × 2160. Linear PCM, HEVC


1st attempt

I choose importing of video clips (4K) and chose both optimized and proxy.

That led to video that wasn't proxy and when creating those clips into a multicam clip my iMac Pro (2017 choked trying to playback the video. I searched and found the proxy files but couldn't figure out how to replace the heavy cpu clips the import created (over many hours of importing and rendering).


I gave up on that. Wished there was a 'replace video with proxy files from...' option. I couldn't find one.


2nd attempt

I imported the clips to a new project and choose only to import at proxy.

I also chose the option to get rid of audio that were empty.

As I notice with the 1st attempt I was getting clips with 8 mono audio tracks

and couldn't hear the audio until I went into the audio info window of each clip and changed that setting from 8 mono to 4 stereo. Then I could hear the audio to audition a clip for in and out points to import into the time line.

So to hopefully eliminate that step of going from 8 mono to 4 stereo on every clip, I choose to "remove silent channels'.


The result :

Now I have proxy video with no audio at all???


Can someone explain to me how to set up my import window to get both Proxys that will work well in my 2017 iMac Pro?

2.5 Ghz 14-core Xeon W

Radeon Pro Vega 64 - 16 GB

128 GB 2666 MHz DDR4

Ventura 13.7.5


I have Final Cut Pro 10.8.1


thx, LG

iMac Pro

Posted on May 7, 2025 1:15 PM

Reply

Similar questions

5 replies
Sort By: 

May 7, 2025 2:12 PM in response to el professor

I stopped using Remove silent channels many FCP versions ago because it would mistakenly remove tracks from older Sony cameras we were using. I haven't tried it again in many years.


You should be able to select all the clips that have 8 mono and change them to 4 stereo at the same time, not one by one. Also, are there really 4 stereo tracks that are needed?


Consider setting your import prefs to Leave Files in Place. This will just point to the media and not make duplicates in your library. Also, if you select the library in the browser, then in the Inspector click Modify Settings for Storage Locations, you can set the Media location to be adjacent to the library so the proxies will be created in a folder, not inside the library. Easy to delete or send to another editor.


If you want to encode proxies at the same time as import, check the box. I typically import first (which is quick with Leave in Place) and create proxies later so I can take a look at the full-res footage first.


Import settings in Final Cut Pro for Mac - Apple Support

Create optimized and proxy files in Final Cut Pro for Mac - Apple Support

Reply

May 7, 2025 1:57 PM in response to el professor

You are not supposed to move any files. To switch to proxy, just select “Proxy Preferred” in the View menu at the top right of the Viewer.


And FWIW there is no need to create both proxy and optimized.


Please tell us your mac model and what drive has your media, how it is connected and formatted. Three streams of optimized media are not expected to play smoothly from a HD but an SSD should handle it fine.

Reply

May 7, 2025 6:56 PM in response to Luis Sequeira1

As per my original posting:

2017 iMac Pro?

2.5 Ghz 14-core Xeon W

Radeon Pro Vega 64 - 16 GB

128 GB 2666 MHz DDR4

Ventura 13.7.5


I use a Promise RAID for my video work.

Thunderbolt 3 connection


the former owner edited one year long project (documentary shot in HD in India) that was shown in theaters in a 2 hr format, then sold it to me before moving. It's a good intel chip based machine, now replaced by the apple silicon me products. I need to wait until making the upgrade.


I have Final Cut Pro 10.8.1

Reply

May 8, 2025 5:52 AM in response to el professor

I have an old iMac Pro that I still love. It's almost as powerful as my M1 Max MBP. That machine isn't the issue. But if you get an external drive, make sure it's fast enough to edit 4K video on, and connect it with the cable it comes with. Be sure to format it APFS. You'll be good to go. It should also support the latest macOS and FCP versions. That iMac Pro is a really good Mac, one of the best Apple ever made. Only reason I upgraded is my fans are going bad and the iMac Pro overheats a couple of times a day.

Reply

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

My proxy import has no audio after choosing "remove silent channels'.

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.