Let me repeat! I have never participated in a "free for 1 year" subscription with Experian. I'm not sure if everyone is reading what I'm saying. I was provided Experian services for free because of a data breach of a site where my information was leaked onto the dark web. That company offered free credit monitoring services for ONE YEAR! Experian would try to sell their services on a landing page and the person could opt out and proceed to the free subscription. Experian never sent any text messages, e-mails, or any communication about an expiring subscription, free or paid, at ANY time. I simply noticed one day that they tried to bill my Apple card. Why, I have no idea. The Apple App Store has never offered any Experian services. If you received close to 10 e-mails from Experian then your case is different than my situation. I would not need Experian services since I can still check my credit for free. I will repeat, the only reason I used Experian is because it was offered FREE for me to use for one year to monitor my credit file on behalf of another company because of their data breach! Whew! Any questions about that? Now, if someone knows the answer I would appreciate the input. If you don't, please read what I have said carefully and not offer simple responses that do not apply to my situation. Again, is it illegal for Experian to bill someone without an option to opt-out?