Logic Pro - Have to click on track to load each plugin upon opening project.

Upon opening an existing Logic file, usually around half of my instrument plugins do not load automatically. Kontakt being the most notorious for doing this. The plugin is still green in the mixer/channel strip but the text is greyed out and no audio comes out after pressing play. I have to manually click on each track to get it to load. This seems to happen more on larger sessions.

It seems like the behavior of the "only load plugins needed for project playback" setting, but I have that disabled. I re-enabled, and then disabled and saved and relaunched Logic multiple times to be sure. The behavior described above is consistent and reproducible on my machine.

Let me know what other info I can provide. Thanks!