Importing and Playing CD songs in Music App

I have an external SuperDrive. I've done this dozens of times in the past, seamlessly. But, today I tried to Play and/or Import a CD of songs, and I get Error 54. The songs will neither Play, nor be copied into Music. I must admit, I have not done this since upgrading to Sonoma. I tried 2 different CD's.

I tested the same SuperDrive in an older iMac with same CD and it worked fine with iTunes.